Well I started it last night and was surprised that I really enjoyed the first two episodes. It was the usual Ryan Murphy pretty boy parade for sure. The guy playing Jack Castello is unbelievably gorgeous. I think after I saw him on screen I was hooked anyway I probably would have watched on just for him. However I did really like the first two episodes. I thought it looked great and had a unique feel to it all. And the episodes seemed to race by so quickly, always a sign I enjoy it. And then episode three happened. I mean, what the hell was that actress they cast to play Vivien Leigh? Perhaps one of the greatest and most beautiful actresses to have ever graced the silver screen. Here played as a really hammy parody of her. And not even addressing her manic depressive nature in a tactful way. She's not a lead in the show, more of a background character but the actress that's playing her is awful and how they have covered her mental illness so far is horrible. A quick bang in the pool house is all that's needed to cure her manic episode? That was the first strike against the show for me. Patti Lupone being rammed over a banister by a 27yr old hunk I could deal with but not that...
I also am sort of having a hard time with trying to deal with these current topics and ideas being placed in a 1940s landscape. I know a lot of stuff went on then just as it does now. I know there were predatory agents like Henry Wilson. I know how people got parts, I know there were gay, bi, lesbian people back then too obviously. I just cant seem to buy the fantasy land where Rock Hudson yells at Noel Coward to stop dancing with his man. His black gay boyfriend, in what? 1948?, at a George Cukor's house.
I know that the whole point of this show is a revisionism. A what if scenario, where freedoms are granted and we see people get a happier life than the one they actually lead. It's just hard to take the melding of the two realities. It's early days though just three episodes in and I am adjusting to how we are shifting from a reality to more a fantasyland. Which is I guess what Hollywood is all about anyway.
There are of course overly cloying bits like Eleanor Roosevelt showing up at the studio to convince these two new oodly progressive movie bosses that they need to cast a black actress as the lead in their film as a way to change America for the better. It's just so odd because it's so not what would have happened. You just have to keep in mind that the premise of the show isn't what happened, but what could/should have happened.
So far from what I have seen I think I can already see the ending coming. In the story they are making the movie Peg, about a young actress disillusioned with Hollywood, who never gets the break she needs, turns to drink and jumps off the Hollywood sign. I predict, from what I have seen so far that Patty Lupone's daughter, Claire who's had a screen test for the role of Peg, will not get the part, become disillusioned with Hollywood, turn to drink and jump off the Hollywood sign. It just seems obvious, maybe too obvious. Well we'll see.
Funnily enough just recently I bought Scotty Bowers book. He's the guy who was the inspiration for the gas station plot with all the extra services provided for the Hollywood rich and famous. Taking them all to Dreamland. I haven.t read the book yet, but have read a little about him already.
I mean how could I stop watching?