Telly Talk Top 5 Five Star

[Emelee]

I will try this one, which is a version of the Artist Top 10.

Each round, a member is allowed to choose 5 songs by an artist or a band. Then it's up to everyone who wants to join in to each rank these 5 songs, from 1 to 5. 1 being the song you like most, 2 the second best song in your opinion etc. etc. At the end of each round, I will count the results and present the winning song for each artist or band. After that, I will present the next round.

---

The winners, so far:

Whitney Houston - One Moment In Time
Mariah Carey - Vision Of Love
Steve Grand - Disciple
Anita Meyer - They Don't Play Out Lovesong Anymore
Weeping Willows - My Love Is Not Blind
Mandy Barnett - More Lovin'
Mary MacGregor - Alone Too Long
Years & Years - Eyes Shut
Blossoms - Texia
Carola - Heaven In My Arms
Yungblud - Polygraph Eyes
Spargo - Just For You
Steps - One For Sorrow
Juice Newton - Angel Of The Morning
Lili & Susie - Oh Mama
Paloma Faith - (a tie between) Only Love Can Hurt Like This & Better Than This
Diana Ross - I'm in the World
Paul Heaton & Jacqui Abbott - (a tie between) Sundial in the Shade & 7" Singles
Marcia Hines - Your Love (Still Brings Me To My Knees)
Beyoncé - Crazy In Love

---

So if I begin with Whitney Houston, I will choose 5 songs of hers. Then you all (and I), each rank them from favourite to least favourite (1-5). When the deadline has passed, we tally up the scores and see which of the 5 songs that wins.

The 5 songs I've chosen are:

• All at Once
• One Moment In Time
• Run to You
• My Love is Your Love
• Didn't We Almost Have It All

Now, you rank these 5 songs from 1-5.

Last day for voting is Friday October 16

 

[Toni]

I will try this one, which is a version of the Artist Top 10.

Each round, a member is allowed to choose 5 songs by an artist or a band and then it's up to everyone who wants to join in to each rank these 5 songs, from 1 to 5.

So if I begin with Whitney Houston, I will choose 5 songs of hers. Then you all (and I), each rank them from favourite to least favourite (1-5). When the deadline has passed, we tally up the scores and see which of the 5 songs that wins.

The 5 songs I've chosen are:

• All at Once
• One Moment In Time
• Run to You
• My Love is Your Love
• Didn't We Almost Have It All

Now, you rank these 5 songs from 1-5.

Last day for voting is Friday October 16

Voilà my votes:
1- Run to You
2- One Moment In Time
3- Didn't We Almost Have It All
4- All at Once
5- My Love is Your Love

 

[Barbara Fan]

The 3 songs I've chosen are:

• 1. One Moment In Time
• 2. Didn't We Almost Have It All
• 3. My Love is Your Love

I dont rememebr the other 2 very well so havent included

 

[Mel O'Drama]

1. One Moment In Time
2. Didn't We Almost Have It All
3. All At Once
4. Run To You

My Love Is Your Love isn't my cup of tea at all so doesn't appear in my list.

 

[Emelee]

The 3 songs I've chosen are:

• 1. One Moment In Time
• 2. Didn't We Almost Have It All
• 3. My Love is Your Love

I dont rememebr the other 2 very well so havent included

1. One Moment In Time
2. Didn't We Almost Have It All
3. Run To You
4. All At Once

My Love Is Your Love isn't my cup of tea at all so doesn't appear in my list.

Well, Iwill put them on the bottom of your lists, cause all songs should be included - no matter if you like them or not.

 

[Jimmy Todd]

All at Once
Didn't We Almost Have it All
One Moment in Time
Run to You
My Love is Your Love

 

[Karin Schill]

1. One Moment in Time
2. Run to You
3. My Love is Your Love
4. All at Once
5. Didn't We Almost Have it All

 

[Angela Channing]

1. One Moment In Time
2. Didn't We Almost Have It All
3. All at Once
4. My Love is Your Love
5. Run to You

 

[Jason73]

1. One Moment In Time
2. Didn't We Almost Have it All
3. Run to You
4. All at Once
5.My Love is Your Love

I like the interesting and surprising choices of songs. MLIYL is such an outlier compared to the other songs.

 

[Sarah]

She’s my absolute favourite singer

1. My Love is Your Love
2. One Moment in Time
3. Run to You
4. Didn’t We Almost Have it All
5. All At Once

 

[Ome]

1. My Love Is Your Love
2. One Moment in Time
3. Didn't We Always Have it All
4. Run to You
5. All at Once

 

[Emelee]

I like the interesting and surprising choices of songs. MLIYL is such an outlier compared to the other songs.

I chose my 5 favourite songs by her.

 

[Emelee]

If anyone here wants to choose an artist or a band
for TT's Top 5, then send me a private message with
the artist or band you want as well as the 5 songs
you want us to rank. ​

 

[Emelee]

Since I don't care to only be hosting, I will be joining in as a voter as well. And as I already revealed, I chose the 5 Whitney-songs that I like the best for this round.

1. My Love Is Your Love
2. Didn't We Almost Have It All
3. One Moment In Time
4. All At Once
5. Run To You

 

[Jason73]

I chose my 5 favourite songs by her.

They are all songs I love, though I don’t know if any of them would be in my top ten.

 

[Emelee]

10 people voted.

1. One Moment In Time 43 points
2. Didn't We Almost Have It All 33 points
3. My Love is Your Love 27 points
4. Run to You 24 points
5. All at Once 22 points


Thanks for voting!

 

[Emelee]

Next round is a choice by @Jason73 who has chosen these

5 Mariah Carey songs

Click song titles for youtube video

Vision of Love
Emotions
Dreamlover
Fantasy
Honey


Rank these 5 songs from 1-5 where 1 is your favourite and 5 is your least favourite of them. You need to rank all 5 songs as each song needs to get points.

Last day for voting is Friday October 23






​

 

[Barbara Fan]

None of the above for me, one i switch over the radio station when she comes on

 

[Mel O'Drama]

After listening a couple of times and re-ordering, they've ended up exactly as they're listed above, which seems like bad form somehow.

1. Vision Of Love
2. Emotions
3. Dreamlover
4. Fantasy
5. Honey

Turns out I like Mariah more than I'd realised. I certainly liked all of these tracks, and the top four quite a lot, so I'm glad of the chance to explore them. Thanks Jason.

 

[Willie Oleson]

Her music sounds a bit alien to me so maybe that's a good reason to revisit it.

1. Vision Of Love
2. Fantasy
3. Emotions
4. Dreamlover
5. Honey (?)