I've waited for this video for a long time:
I've watched this video twice since it's been uploaded. Well, I've watched it once all the way through, and the second time, I skimmed it.
As it appears, there were only three major contenders for the Best Actress Oscar win in 1950: Bette Davis, Gloria Swanson, and Judy Holliday.
I've never seen CAGED, which got Eleanor Parker her nomination, but I feel like she was really the weakest link of the five women nominated.
Anne Baxter, to me at least, seems to have sabotaged her own campaign. I understand why she wouldn't have wanted to be nominated again as Best Supporting Actress, but it might've increased her chances to win. But even if she had done that, there was no guarantee that she would've won that, either. Baxter's performance in ALL ABOUT EVE is quite good, but it's Davis' movie. They just had to know Davis was going to walk away with the best notices and publicity.
In a perfect world, Paramount should've released SUNSET BOULEVARD in late 1949, then Swanson could've won in 1950. ALL ABOUT EVE should've came out in 1950, and Davis could've won in 1951. BORN YESTERDAY should've been withheld until 1951, and Holliday could've won in 1952. But none of it would've worked that way. I just know it wouldn't've.
Going with the nominations we were given, Davis and Swanson should've tied for the win in 1950. They both gave superb performances as two separate aging actresses. It was a prime year for a tie.