My Cliff Barnes Theory

cardiff1984

Telly Talk Active Member
LV
0
 
Messages
213
Reaction score
136
Awards
1
Location
England
The reason for Cliff becoming evil and psychotic in new Dallas, was never really explained. In the 11th season of OD, Cliff made peace with Ellie and seemingly put closure to the Barnes/Ewing feud. He became close to Bobby and Christopher and only had few run ins with JR, prior to getting control of Ewing Oil in 1991. When watching the beginning of TNT Dallas, Chris had a dislike to his uncle and suggested Cliff wanted to do everything to screw over the Ewings and it appeared Cliff felt the urge to carry on that vendetta, which led to his vicious crimes, killing his unborn grand children and going to prison. Cliff was a bumbling idiot, whom had his failings, his cunning ways. At the beginning of OD, he was a likeable character. Even, after he accidentally killed Johnny Dancer, he was guilt ridden and was willing to go to prison to get Mckay off the hook, but was saved by a mistrial. Something big or terrible happened between 1991-2012, which tipped Cliff over the edge. Here's my theory. It may sound far fetched.

Sometime in the 90s or early 2000s, Cliff tracks down Katherine Wentworth and demands the whereabouts of Pam. Katherine hands Cliff an old diary of Rebecca's and the contents are shocking. It reveals Rebecca was struggling with Digger's continuous ways and Digger disappeared for weeks on end and Jock was a shoulder to cry on. She had a one night stand with Jock. Jock was Cliff's father. Katherine laughs and taunts Cliff and in a fit of rage, he murders Katherine and covers up her murder. He finds a way to make it look like in her will, that she makes him conservitore of her entire estate. As the years go by, Cliff realizes, the real reason Pam left, because she feared Katherine would find her and decided not to return to protect Bobby and Christopher. What sends Cliff over the edge even more is that the cancer, she died from, progressed too quick, due to Neurofibomatosis. Which proves she was Digger's Daughter after all. He wasn't a Barnes, but she was. Cliff gets it into his head, that Jock knew he was his father and that he allowed himself and JR to hurt, both him and Digger and that Rebecca abandoned him and Pam, because of her guilt of being mother to Jocks son. During the 1990s or 2000s, Cliff sells Ewing Oil during a merger and his bitterness towards the Ewings reoccurs, which leaves the Ewings bewildered.
 
Last edited:

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
LV
5
 
Messages
22,958
Reaction score
39,428
Awards
17
Location
Bethpage, NY
Jock. Jock was Cliff's father
This alone would be enough to send Cliff over the edge for good. I can see the fact of learning he was really a Ewing all along doing irreparable damage to him mentally.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
LV
5
 
Messages
22,958
Reaction score
39,428
Awards
17
Location
Bethpage, NY
I'd hoped one day we'd discover J.R. was Ellie and Digger's love child
This would’ve been the perfect way to end the series. A freeze frame of J.R.’s face after he learns the truth.


Cliff Ewing
Perhaps this would be overkill but what if they both found out in the end they had different fathers than who they thought?
 

xab

Telly Talk Active Member
LV
0
 
Messages
274
Reaction score
438
Awards
5
Location
france
Sometimes I'm amazed ... I'm not sure we watched the same show... Cliff always been a terrible and manipulative and insensitive and selfish prick.... Just ask poor Afton or anybody who crossed his path. He used many people, from Sue-Ellen (love at first sight, my ass) to his own mother. And what about Jamie ? He didn't give a f*** about her death. He just ogled her will. I'm not surprised he did hide Pam's death from Christopher (and Bobby). Typical Cliff. What happened between 1991 and 2012 ? Nobody knows, and nobody will, but I don't think we need a brain tumor explanation. He just got older and more embittered than ever. Ok, he used to have a few emotional times back in the days and shed a tear or two, proving he was a human being after all, but he's got bitterness under his skin (for whatever reasons, not all related to the Ewings)

I'm not the guy I used (or try or look ?) to be 20 years ago. But I'm still myself deep inside. For better or (unfortunately sometimes...) for worse... I know my dark sides. I struggled, but who knows how the show will end ?

I know the season two (TNT) oil rig explosion leading to Pamela's miscarriage (just like auntie Pam... Let's talk about karma...) seems out of character for Cliff but I really didn't feel they jumped any sharks.

Just have a look to Ken Kercheval's acting before the infamous "just do it". His face. I trust the actor. He knows better than us about his character. When asked about the oil rig explosion, It's not a big clear yes from Barnes. It obviously is : hate is stronger than me.

And I'm afraid this is definitely the Cliff Barnes we met forty years ago...

Hate was always stronger than love...

 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
LV
5
 
Messages
17,511
Reaction score
6,260
Awards
15
Location
In that attic above Falcon Crest
I've said for years that we should find out that both Cliff and Pam had developed adult-onset neurofibromatosis (the two siblings between them died of it in childhood -- which is usually when it happens). But it can, and sometimes does, manifest in adulthood.

Once Pam had her crash in 1987 and was burned from head-to-toe, her immune system was threatened, and the neurofibromatosis kicked in. Killing her in the shadows during, say, 1989 or 1990 or 1991, while the series was winding down. Perhaps Bobby and Cliff could find some evidence that suggests this, but are unable to substantiate it concretely. Even if it doesn't get explained until 2013.

Then, in nuDALLAS, Cliff has dun gone out-of-character crazy because the late-onset neurofibromatosis has created brain lesions in his head.

So now he's a maniac.

Job done.

xab said:
Just have a look to Ken Kercheval's acting before the infamous "just do it". His face. I trust the actor. He knows better than us about his character. When asked about the oil rig explosion, It's not a big clear yes from Barnes. It obviously is : hate is stronger than me.

And I'm afraid this is definitely the Cliff Barnes we met forty years ago...

Hate was always stronger than love...

We can be so loose with the word "love". Hate is only stronger when the love isn't real. One could argue Cliff -- and most of the Ewings -- were too narcissistic to ever genuinely love anybody. (And does that apply to most people?). And does that translate into goofy Cliff from the '80s willing to kill his daughter and unborn grandchildren just to screw over the Ewings one more time in the 2010s?

I sometimes wonder: did Ken Kercheval ever question his homicidal "just do it!" line??

I still say: brain lesions, borne of neurofibromatosis --- I mean, for God's sake, it's already in the back story!
 
Last edited:

Jock Ewing Fan

Telly Talk Enthusiast
LV
0
 
Messages
2,277
Reaction score
3,720
Awards
8
Location
USA
Favourite Movie
Indiana Jones
Some thoughts.

Cliff won what was Ewing Oil at the time in 1991.
Why would he remain so bitter?

At the beginning of the original series, Cliff did have some legitimate complaints about the Ewings.
They did oppose in in two elections with some heavy handed tactics.
However, Cliff did undermine himself, particularly when Bobby was trying to help him

Was Afton really any better?
An affair with JR, then the Wentworth family was quite wealthy and powerful.
Cliff did have a legitimate argument about the drill
Cliff's responsibility was to maximize the profitability of Barnes-Wentworth, its' investors, employees, contractors, vendors, financial institutions, etc.
If that meant using the drill for his company, so be it.
Ewing Oil and who owns it is not his priority.
If Cliff was to be personally involved in who owns Ewing Oil, he would have favored Bobby
and opposed JR.

Over time, his feud with the Ewings did impair his judgement,
and was not beneficial to him.
In later seasons after VP left, however, he seemed to soften for a while.
Eventually though, he owned Ewing Oil, and that led to TNT Dallas
(which seemed to ignore the TV movies)
 

southfork88

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
LV
0
 
Messages
1,516
Reaction score
2,390
Awards
4
Location
Italy
Member Since
2008
I've said for years that we should find out that both Cliff and Pam had developed adult-onset neurofibromatosis (the two siblings between them died of it in childhood -- which is usually when it happens). But it can, and sometimes does, manifest in adulthood.

Once Pam had her crash in 1987 and was burned from head-to-toe, her immune system was threatened, and the neurofibromatosis kicked in. Killing her in the shadows during, say, 1989 or 1990 or 1991, while the series was winding down. Perhaps Bobby and Cliff could find some evidence that suggests this, but are unable to substantiate it concretely. Even if it doesn't get explained until 2013.

Then, in nuDALLAS, Cliff has dun gone out-of-character crazy because the late-onset neurofibromatosis has created brain lesions in his head.

So now he's a maniac.

Job done.



We can be so loose with the word "love". Hate is only stronger when the love isn't real. One could argue Cliff -- and most of the Ewings -- were too narcissistic to ever genuinely love anybody. (And does that apply to most people?). And does that translate into goofy Cliff from the '80s willing to kill his daughter and unborn grandchildren just to screw over the Ewings one more time in the 2010s?

I sometimes wonder: did Ken Kercheval ever question his homicidal "just do it!" line??

I still say: brain lesions, borne of neurofibromatosis --- I mean, for God's sake, it's already in the back story!

By the way, when Cliff attempted suicide in 1982, doctors said he might have a personality change. I'm not making this up, and neurofibromatosis could have made things worse.
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
LV
0
 
Messages
508
Reaction score
760
Awards
4
Location
United States
Member Since
2016
Some thoughts.

Cliff won what was Ewing Oil at the time in 1991.
Why would he remain so bitter?

At the beginning of the original series, Cliff did have some legitimate complaints about the Ewings.
They did oppose in in two elections with some heavy handed tactics.
However, Cliff did undermine himself, particularly when Bobby was trying to help him

Was Afton really any better?
An affair with JR, then the Wentworth family was quite wealthy and powerful.
Cliff did have a legitimate argument about the drill
Cliff's responsibility was to maximize the profitability of Barnes-Wentworth, its' investors, employees, contractors, vendors, financial institutions, etc.
If that meant using the drill for his company, so be it.
Ewing Oil and who owns it is not his priority.
If Cliff was to be personally involved in who owns Ewing Oil, he would have favored Bobby
and opposed JR.

Over time, his feud with the Ewings did impair his judgement,
and was not beneficial to him.
In later seasons after VP left, however, he seemed to soften for a while.
Eventually though, he owned Ewing Oil, and that led to TNT Dallas
(which seemed to ignore the TV movies)
Great analysis. Cliff's turn into what we saw on Dallas TNT made no logical sense. I have read that Ken Kercheval was not coming back to the series. If that is true, I don't blame him. It was horrible what they did to his character. Blowing up a platform with people standing on it is evil enough but with your pregnant daughter standing there is the act of a monster. Then he disappears for days like a coward and when he shows up, the first thing he says to his daughter, who he almost killed, is that she has to forgive him. That was awful.
 
Top