This thread reminds me of how fun it was watching the show for the first time. I hope you're enjoying it!
The show did have its issues, especially in its first season. What I still remember is the somewhat annoying faux-cliffhangers -- life-or-death situations so we can end the episode, which were resolved within seconds at the beginning of the next. Also, too many secondary characters with little to no story, personality, or interest, causing the show to feel like it didn't have much plot going on. BUT: They were willing to pay attention to what was working and what wasn't. They went with what felt organically right, and it helped tremendously. That's why it started as the Fallon/Jeff show but then shifted attention to Sable/Jason/Zach etc. The show followed what worked. I thought the show got better and better even as Season 1 progressed and certainly showed massive improvement in Season 2; even Bliss was given decent story.
The only ones they never managed to make click was Fallon and, to a lesser extent, Jeff. I still don't understand why they just couldn't adjust course with Fallon.
Overall, I enjoyed the show tremendously and think it's a shame it never got its third season.