while the characters endlessly queried each other about their "feelings" and then told each other they were wrong to feel that way.
It's when the opinion itself becomes the topic of conversation, while in reality the Dynasty characters stopped having opinions.
A catty insult doesn't mean much if we don't know how much they hate each other.
Of course it's easier to write an opinion of the new stepmother (season 1 and 2) than to say something about Rita. But Knots Landing would not take the easy way out, even if would (unintentionally) emphasize how ridiculously soapy a storyline is.
That's why Claudia's strongly opinionated behaviour in season 6 looks so disproportionately refreshing. It doesn't matter if it makes perfect sense or not, it simply adds an exciting perspective to the soap's status quo.
It makes us less certain of
what we're watching, and that's far more thrilling than physical events like car crashes and doppelgangers.
Maybe that's why I like the dynamics in THE COLBYS and NEW DALLAS so much (ha, I
knew there was a connection!)
Early years Blake Carrington had an opinion of homosexuals, it was dark and ugly but it was
something and that "something" put the other characters in an uncomfortable position.
I believe that the beginning of the prime time soap renaissance (even if PEYTON PLACE was the only series that came before it) was strongly intertwined with the popularity of the mini-series of the 1970s which actually were not called "mini-series" at the time of the original broadcasts.
They were "television events" or even "an X hour motion picture" as a way to distinguish between regular TV episodes (e.g. sitcoms, westerns, police adventures) and the more ambitious and cinematic productions (e.g.
Roots,
Centennial,
Rich Man Poor Man).
I'm not saying that this connection was intentional since KNOTS LANDING was supposed to be the first one, and DALLAS just feels more inherently eventful.
Looking at the early years of DALLAS, DYNASTY and FALCON CREST I find it very noticeable that there are no "what if" scenarios. The things that need to happen play out in a way that has a very "live" feel to it. The stories unfold in a very organic way.
Fast-forward to the mid-eighties and what we see in these soaps is the Potential Problem being introduced, with the unspoken question "what IF it's going to affect the characters".
It's when the theory of the TV eventfulness becomes more important than the event itself, and that's how you end up with Moldavia nonsense.
When Blake killed Ted Dinard there was no time to think about that, it happened and they simply had to deal with it.
The soapy doppelganger impostor is a preposterous plot device but still there was something organic in the way RITA happened (and started to happen).
There was not much time to think about Sammy Jo's luck to meet a person who
reminded her of auntie Krystle, it just happened, and then the devious plot sort of spontaneously came into existence.
I'm not sure if they made the
most of it, but there is something intriguing about the other characters not knowing who they're dealing with (especially Alexis when she sees her opinion of the "trashy two-faced Krystle" validated. Actually this is not how she really feels about Krystle, it's how she
wants to feel about Krystle - but that's a different topic altogether).
At the same time we're watching Rita trying to keep up appearances while Sammy Jo sees her evil plot getting hijacked by Joel Abrigore who - as we all unanimously agree - should have been played by Anthony Perkins.
Meanwhile, the real Krystle watches the literal identity theft on live television in horror and bewilderment.
Maybe that's why Dominique's
fabulous dark secret is the worst Dynasty plot ever written. Because strong opinions were not allowed, and everything about Dominique came to an abrupt standstill, except for a few half-baked conflicts with Alexis who - to make matters worse - always looked kinda bored.
To Dominique's credit, she never stopped taking herself extremely seriously and many of her scenes are embarrassingly funny.
imho.