Supposedly good characters you couldn't stand and bad ones you liked

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Member
We're there any characters we were supposed to believe we're good people which you didn't like or any bad ones you liked?

For me the main one was Ray. I hated him from the first because of the hayloft frolics with Lucy, because he went to Waco womanizing with JR, sucked up to him and helped him set up Pam. Then I hated him because he cheated on Donna. Ironically, the only time I liked him was when he was violent.....towards JR.

I also found Pam insufferable at times with her lectures and self righteousness. I did admire the way she took responsibility for Lucy when nobody else would. That was good of her. I never could warm to the character though. I think part of that was because I didn't think much of Principal's acting.

Her boyfriend Mark, OTOH, I considered nothing more than an egotistical douchebag. Plus that pornstache! Yuck!

I also disliked Mitch Cooper. What a priggish, self involved, sexist jerk.

Afton was awful too. She was another one who gave lectures and moralized even though she had been corrupt as hell with JR and was openly a gold digger. If there's one thing I can't stand it's a hypocrite.

As for the bad ones, Sue Ellen did a lot of horrible things, but I liked her. Maybe it was because she was the only major female character on the show who had an actual character arc. Maybe it was because she got all those great lines insulting JR. At any rate, she was great TV.
I also couldn't help rooting for Cliff, even though he got more narcissistic as the show went on. He started off as a seemingly decent guy and devolved into a cretin. But he was hilarious to watch. As with Sue Ellen there was a character arc which made him interesting, even though it was negative. JR, OTOH, started off a creep and stayed a creep. I did love Hangman's portrayal of him though.
 
Last edited:

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
We're there any characters we were supposed to believe we're good people which you didn't like or any bad ones you liked?

For me the main one was Ray. I hated him from the first because of the hayloft frolics with Lucy, because he went to Waco womanizing with JR, sucked up to him and helped him set up Pam. Then I hated him because he cheated on Donna. Ironically, the only time I liked him was when he was violent.....towards JR.

I also found Pam insufferable at times with her lectures and self righteousness. I did admire the way she took responsibility for Lucy when nobody else would. That was good of her. I never could warm to the character though. I think part of that was because I didn't think much of Principal's acting.

Her boyfriend Mark, OTOH, I considered nothing more than an egotistical douchebag. Plus that pornstache! Yuck!

I also disliked Mitch Cooper. What a priggish, self involved, sexist jerk.

Afton was awful too. She was another one who gave lectures and moralized even though she had been corrupt as hell with JR and was openly a gold digger. If there's one thing I can't stand it's a hypocrite.

As for the bad ones, Sue Ellen did a lot of horrible things, but I liked her. Maybe it was because she was the only major female character on the show who had an actual character arc. Maybe it was because she got all those great lines insulting JR. At any rate, she was great TV.
I also couldn't help rooting for Cliff, even though he got more narcissistic as the show went on. He started off as a seemingly decent guy and devolved into a cretin. But he was hilarious to watch. As with Sue Ellen there was a character arc which made him interesting, even though it was negative. JR, OTOH, started off a creep and stayed a creep. I did love Hangman's portrayal of him though.

We agree on several.. The Afton one made me take notice, though because I think you might be the first person I have seen here that feels that way, and it's a very valid point. I wonder why April's change offends so many, but Afton's did not? Is it because April ended up with Bobby? Because April was a later addition?

Are you saying that you think we were supposed to not see Sue Ellen as a good person? I'm not sure if I'm misunderstanding, or if that's your take? I always thought she was a little more of a lost soul. Someone that had good intentions underneath the coldness she could sometimes exude. In search of herself.
 
Last edited:

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Member
We agree on several.. The Afton one made me take notice, though because I think you might be the first person I have seen here that feels that way, and it's a very valid point. I wonder why April's change offends so many, but Afton's did not? Is it because April ended up with Bobby? Because April was a later addition?

Are you saying that you think we were supposed to not see Sue Ellen as a good person? I'm not sure if I'm misunderstanding, or if that's your take? I always thought she was a little more of a lost soul. Someone that had good intentions underneath the coldness she could sometimes exude. In search of herself.
I think we were supposed to see Sue Ellen as complicated, not all bad, but not really good. The show had a way of defining their characters by the praise of other characters. For example, Donna, Bobby, Pam, Jock and Miss Ellie saying what a great guy Ray was and everybody saying how wonderful Bobby was. We didn't get any of that with Sue Ellen. Only rarely did anyone express a positive thought about her. I certainly don't think we were supposed to approve of her sleeping with married men and young boys (Clint and Peter) and her drunk driving. I think she was meant to be seen as a "sinner" but at the same time we were supposed to sympathize with her plight.

As for Afton vs April, that's a great point. They went through a similar transformation, though I did like that April didn't go on to hector others about their lack of moral fibre like Afton did. So at least she wasn't hypocritical. I do think that the way April was initially portrayed was a shade nastier than Afton, so maybe that's why her transformation rankles some people more. Or maybe it's because Bobby is so sacred to them that they feel he deserved somebody without a sleazy past. I certainly liked April better for him than Jenna as portrayed by Priscilla, who IMO was wooden and dreary with almost nothing in the way of a discernable personality.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
Mark, OTOH, I considered nothing more than an egotistical douchebag. Plus that pornstache! Yuck!

I also disliked Mitch Cooper. What a priggish, self involved, sexist jerk.
I didn’t particularly like Mark either, but since Pam eventually needed a permanent love interest, I’m glad it was Mark rather than Alex Ward or John Don Ford. John Beck was actually quite convincing in a role that I personally found unlikable—the same, unfortunately, cannot be said for Leigh McCloskey as Mitch. I later saw Leigh McCloskey in daytime soaps and found him convincing there—especially in Santa Barbara—but in Dallas, he just didn’t quite resonate with me. I wonder if Mitch could have worked as a character if someone else had played him, though I can’t think of any suitable candidates off the top of my head.

I didn’t like Jenna, played by Priscilla Presley. In her first two seasons, she served her purpose—much like Mark (neither of them were characters I liked, but they were good for the show)—but in her final three seasons, she was, for me, nothing more than dead weight.

I liked Rebecca, even though she was quite unfair to Cliff and, above all, to Pam. Consider how she behaved toward Pam when Pam discovered her: first, she convincingly denied being her mother; then, she asked Pam to keep quiet about it, claiming her husband was in such poor health—yet, at the same time, he was fit enough to keep working, fly around, and attend charity events with his wife. Furthermore, once Rebecca had secured a good secretarial job, she certainly would have had enough time to reach out to her children. There were, therefore, plenty of reasons to dislike Rebecca, but Priscilla Pointer’s performance made me appreciate her.
 

Scorpienne

Telly Talk Active Member
I have to say I was back and forth on Miss Ellie. She could be so wise. But then that whole thing about losing her marbles every time one of her kids even considered moving away from Southfork--in another lifetime she might have been a cult leader or something. Very odd, though it made for excellent television having them all in the same house. But I also feel some of the things she did might explain (though not excuse) JR's behavior.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I also disliked Mitch Cooper. What a priggish, self involved, sexist jerk.
I massively disagree. He made it very clear what kind of life he wanted - admittedly, the severe objection to any kind of adjustment isn't always very appealing - but Lucy could take it or leave it.
She took it and then tried to change his narrative, and not in a very subtle way.
 

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
I massively disagree. He made it very clear what kind of life he wanted - admittedly, the severe objection to any kind of adjustment isn't always very appealing - but Lucy could take it or leave it.
She took it and then tried to change his narrative, and not in a very subtle way.
This is one of the things I love- to this day -about forums such as this. Yes, it's great to feel a sense of community, and being united as people still actually talking about the show today, but it's also pretty cool when someone points out a differing perspective, and it causes me to do a reevaluation of the situation myself.

I'll be honest, I was fully on board with Mitch being insufferable, but your points are valid. Yes, they either wrote the character, or Leigh played it a little too intensely..I'm not sure which. He never lied to Lucy, though. He was upfront from day one, and she just didn't listen..and somewhat led him to believe she was going to fit into his ways. I can see why over time a person in Mitch's position would start to become uptight, rude about the way her and her family kept pushing their ways onto him..the Ewing condo..the offer of the Ewing job(I think I'm remembering this right..or am I thinking of Alan Beam here), then Lucy taking on the modeling.

All of that said, with Mitch, the attitude didn't build over time, it was there from day one, as well as his honesty..so it's a little complex. He just didn't play a really likable character in general. I mean, it's 100% respectable to want to make your own way, but you don't have to carry yourself the way that he did because of it.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
She promised to be a good doctor's wife.
Two days later, a camera crew storms into Mitch's living room to make a reality show about supermodel Lucy's private life.

By the way, how many (fashion) models did the soaps have? (excluding Paper Dolls and Models Inc)
The other Dallas model is Mandy Winger of course, Dynasty's Sammy Jo posed for dirty magazines and blue-collar husband David Palmer became a fashion-sensation in the Australian soap Sons & Daughters.
I think the Knots Landing women modelled for a fashion show in the Jessica Walter episode?
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
In Mitch's defense, the only thing they wrote for him was obstreperousness regarding Lucy's family's money. For two years. So we didn't have much of an opportunity to "like" him too much beyond his fussing. And, yes, he'd warned Lucy about his value system.

Anyway, we can like a character without "liking" a character -- I mean, that's what JR (and Sue Ellen) was all about!
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I don't think I could enjoy these soaps based on real-life morals and values.
To begin with, why even bother with the problems of characters who "have it all" and still find a way to make that privileged life as difficult and dramatic as possible?
It's because they are well-written and entertainingly performed by the actors. And because the Rich Life is pretty to look at.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Speaking on Mitch, he was a poor snob. I can understand having values, but he really took it too far. I know, the writers went over the top with Lucy's modeling gig by having a full fledged photo shoot in his apartment, but he acted like they had to live dirt poor. Did he actually think that was going to work for a woman who had everything?

Ray was perceived as a good guy, and when he wasn't loathing in his self-pity, he was perhaps my favorite overall character. But he did too many bad deeds to be a "good guy" IMO. He treated Donna like crap and I even sometimes wondered what she saw in him. When he cheated on her and even somewhat set it up so she'd find him in bed with Bonnie, Donna should have ran for the hills. Instead she actually gets in to a fight over him. Love Dallas, but they really didn't value women at all, but that's another story for another day.

Bobby was the main good guy, but his self-righteousness really got old. There's many examples of this, but the one that really sticks out to me is when he went to Marilee's home to practically threaten her to not file a lawsuit against the precious Ewing's after JR's crooked Asian Oil deal causes her husband Seth to commit suicide. Marilee should have told Bobby "if you don't get off my property...)

I still think Miss Ellie was a good person, but the more I look at her, she had her faults. Her actions after JR got shot didn't sit well with me. She was totally unfair to Jock and JR during this time, all because she didn't want Bobby to leave. I believe she even told Jock that she'd never forgive him if Bobby left.

With that being said, if the characters weren't as complicated as they were, we wouldn't be here taking about it 35 years after it went off the air. Lol
 
Last edited:

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Member
I didn’t particularly like Mark either, but since Pam eventually needed a permanent love interest, I’m glad it was Mark rather than Alex Ward or John Don Ford. John Beck was actually quite convincing in a role that I personally found unlikable—the same, unfortunately, cannot be said for Leigh McCloskey as Mitch. I later saw Leigh McCloskey in daytime soaps and found him convincing there—especially in Santa Barbara—but in Dallas, he just didn’t quite resonate with me. I wonder if Mitch could have worked as a character if someone else had played him, though I can’t think of any suitable candidates off the top of my head.

I didn’t like Jenna, played by Priscilla Presley. In her first two seasons, she served her purpose—much like Mark (neither of them were characters I liked, but they were good for the show)—but in her final three seasons, she was, for me, nothing more than dead weight.

I liked Rebecca, even though she was quite unfair to Cliff and, above all, to Pam. Consider how she behaved toward Pam when Pam discovered her: first, she convincingly denied being her mother; then, she asked Pam to keep quiet about it, claiming her husband was in such poor health—yet, at the same time, he was fit enough to keep working, fly around, and attend charity events with his wife. Furthermore, once Rebecca had secured a good secretarial job, she certainly would have had enough time to reach out to her children. There were, therefore, plenty of reasons to dislike Rebecca, but Priscilla Pointer’s performance made me appreciate her.
Alex Ward was such an obvious sleaze that I had to wonder what on earth Pam saw in him. So yeah, Mark was certainly an improvement.
I agree with you about Rebecca. She had been terribly selfish regarding her children, yet she was a likeable character.
 

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Member
I have to say I was back and forth on Miss Ellie. She could be so wise. But then that whole thing about losing her marbles every time one of her kids even considered moving away from Southfork--in another lifetime she might have been a cult leader or something. Very odd, though it made for excellent television having them all in the same house. But I also feel some of the things she did might explain (though not excuse) JR's behavior.
Yeah, Miss Ellie bothered me at times too. I remember in an interview Larry Hagman explained that Miss Ellie let JR get away with so much because she just wasn't very bright. I can't say I disagree, though I think it was more that she was in denial about a lot of things.
 

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Member
I massively disagree. He made it very clear what kind of life he wanted - admittedly, the severe objection to any kind of adjustment isn't always very appealing - but Lucy could take it or leave it.
She took it and then tried to change his narrative, and not in a very subtle way.
He did not make it clear beforehand that he objected to her having her own career. He didn't want to live off Ewing money and she did agree to that. She never agreed to not going out and making money herself.
 

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Member
This is one of the things I love- to this day -about forums such as this. Yes, it's great to feel a sense of community, and being united as people still actually talking about the show today, but it's also pretty cool when someone points out a differing perspective, and it causes me to do a reevaluation of the situation myself.

I'll be honest, I was fully on board with Mitch being insufferable, but your points are valid. Yes, they either wrote the character, or Leigh played it a little too intensely..I'm not sure which. He never lied to Lucy, though. He was upfront from day one, and she just didn't listen..and somewhat led him to believe she was going to fit into his ways. I can see why over time a person in Mitch's position would start to become uptight, rude about the way her and her family kept pushing their ways onto him..the Ewing condo..the offer of the Ewing job(I think I'm remembering this right..or am I thinking of Alan Beam here), then Lucy taking on the modeling.

All of that said, with Mitch, the attitude didn't build over time, it was there from day one, as well as his honesty..so it's a little complex. He just didn't play a really likable character in general. I mean, it's 100% respectable to want to make your own way, but you don't have to carry yourself the way that he did because of it.
Exactly. He had that chip on his shoulder from the start.
 

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Member
Speaking on Mitch, he was a poor snob. I can understand having values, but he really took it too far. I know, the writers went over the top with Lucy's modeling gig by having a full fledged photo shoot in his apartment, but he acted like they had to live dirt poor. Did he actually think that was going to work for a woman who had everything?

Ray was perceived as a good guy, and when he wasn't loathing in his self-pity, he was perhaps my favorite overall character. But he did too many bad deeds to be a "good guy" IMO. He treated Donna like crap and I even sometimes wondered what she saw in him. When he cheated on her and even somewhat set it up so she'd find him in bed with Bonnie, Donna should have ran for the hills. Instead she actually gets in to a fight over him. Love Dallas, but they really didn't value women at all, but that's another story for another day.

Bobby was the main good guy, but his self-righteousness really got old. There's many examples of this, but the one that really sticks out to me is when he went to Marilee's home to practically threaten her to not file a lawsuit against the precious Ewing's after JR's crooked Asian Oil deal causes her husband Seth to commit suicide. Marilee should have told Bobby "if you don't get off my property...)

I still think Miss Ellie was a good person, but the more I look at her, she had her faults. Her actions after JR got shot didn't sit well with me. She was totally unfair to Jock and JR during this time, all because she didn't want Bobby to leave. I believe she even told Jock that she'd never forgive him if Bobby left.

With that being said, if the characters weren't as complicated as they were, we wouldn't be here taking about it 35 years after it went off the air. Lol
Agree with all of this.
I was amazed and delighted to find a place where fans are still talking about it.
 
Top