I thought Saint James was too self-conscious to be suited for straight sitcom
I may be being too harsh on her here... I was basing my opinion on her performance in early episodes of KATE & ALLIE (which were pretty rough, and '80s-era stiff) so I gave up quickly on the show.
But I've been catching clips today from later episodes, and Saint James seems much better than I'd remembered. So the series must have improved or at least gotten more into its groove.
The fact that I jumped ship so quickly on KATE & ALLIE is notable, because I'd always liked both Saint James and Jane Curtin.
Never a milquetoast, Curtin today eulogized her former costar by saying: "We lost a decent person today. Susan St. James was a decent person who made Kate and Allie a joy. She juggled a really full life from the Ed Sullivan theater in between working on stage and being the Mom on set. She worked tirelessly for organizations she believed in like the Special Olympics. All the while raising children and going through the horrors of losing a child."
Curtin added, "Susan was my friend and working with her brought such laughter, community and family to the stage at the Ed Sullivan theater. I’ll miss her."