SoapLand - The Battle Of The Illnesses - The Result

Richard Channing

Telly Talk Superstar
LV
13
 
Awards
25
1. Mark's Leukemia
critique-dallas-episode-159-love-stories-1-copy.jpg

2. Cecil's Heart attack(s)
Dynasty40.jpg

3. Ellie's Breast Cancer
dal-list-dallass-35-greatest-moments-so-far-17.jpg


4. Chase is poisoned by Dr. Lantry

5. Laura has terminal cancer
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
LV
5
 
Awards
11
1. Val's colon cancer. The actors involved gave great performances, JVA, TS, ML, and PD. It also helped enrich our understanding of the characters and their relationships, which served the show and the viewers so well as the series progressed. Things didn't have to be clarified or explained because of episodes such as this. We just knew. Also, little lines line the one from Richard about Karen: "She's probably got Val dead and buried already." Knots Landing gold.

2. Diana's kidney failure. For all the reasons posters have already stated as well as the ones I wrote for number 1. Abby was, imho, the best "villainess" on t.v. This episode showed how fascinatingly complex she is. They could have just gone with the "she's bad, but not THAT bad," but they added that wonderful "Go save a whale" exchange between her and Karen. This also conveyed the complex relationship she had with Karen and her children via Sid. A few seasons later when Karen remarks to Abby, "After all, we are family, " it's not a contrived line thrown in there for the current plot. I also liked when she tells Gary that she's scared and that she feels pressured because she has to live among these people, and face them if she decides not to give her kidney. So humanly heroic and self involved at the same time. Knots Landing.

3. Laura's brain tumor It was such an important moment on Knots. A core character was dying, and she was not coming back from the dead as so many others have done. Constance McCashin was so good that even when she didn't have a major plot, she still made her presence felt. She didn't get a dramatic death scene, but she made the most of what they did give her, and her presence was felt through the rest of the series. Knots Landing.

4. Chao-Li's heart attack. Chao-Li was such an important character to the show even if he rarely had a plot. However, he was more than a background character. I'm choosing his illness because of the lovely scenes with him and Angela. It really brought out her humanity, showing she was more than the tough as nails battle axe. One of the most memorable plots, imho. Falcon Crest.

5.The effects of the poison on Greg. Mainly because of William Devane's performance, but also for what it brought out in Paige and Claudia. With Claudia we got perhaps the darkest scene from all of the soaps. Her scheming to get him a kidney(she's not in the will, so she's got to save him), results in her finagling a kidney for him that was supposed to go to a dying man. The episode ending scene of the poor wife crying over her doomed husband as Claudia passes by triumphantly always gets to me. Abby's my favorite villian, but Claudia was always the most disturbing. Knots Landing.
 

Mel O'Drama

Admin
LV
16
 
Awards
44
1. Val's colon cancer
Knots Landing

This marked the first episode of the series I watched and has a special place in my heart for that alone. Include some wonderful performances (Ted Shackelford was terrifyingly good, and the "You don't have any kind of guts" scene remains the best performance Patrick Duffy gave on either series in my eyes) and an achingly beautiful score (albeit recycled due to the musician's strike), and a memorable final line and it's a winning episode.






2. Miss Ellie's breast cancer
Dallas

A wonderful performance from BBG.






3. Laura's brain tumour
Knots Landing

It's been accurately said that Constance McCashin was unfairly sidelined, but I love how much she gave with the little she was given. Knots's trademark combination of pathos and humour was on full display, and there was much warmth and heart. The Gift Of Life is a corker of an episode, thanks to Connie and William Devane at his best.






4. The Barnes Family's neurofibromatosis
Dallas

Much mileage was gained from the underlying condition, and I appreciated that there was no sense of patronising awareness raising or social responsibility. The condition was a means to create further drama and conflict. Pure soapy goodness.






5. Greg's liver failure
Knots Landing

The brutal Claudia scene Jimmy described above makes this one worth the entry fee.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
LV
5
 
Awards
11
View attachment 20905
"…tips the scales of justice ever so slightly in his favour"

I think Claudia should win this battle.

That's what makes it so good. Her utilitarian position makes a lot of sense. We also know Claudia's true motives. Then there is that final heart breaking scene. Such a compelling mix, and this was a show whose seasons were now in the double digits, yet it could still deliver the goods.
There'll never be another Knots Landing.
 
Last edited:

Richard Channing

Telly Talk Superstar
LV
13
 
Awards
25
We've got your results back, and I'm afraid its not good news...


1. Miss Ellie's breast cancer (25 points)

dal-list-dallass-35-greatest-moments-so-far-17.jpg


2. Val's colon cancer (16 points)

3. Mark's leukemia (15 points)

4. Diana's kidney failure (14 points)

5. Maggie's amnesia and Laura's brain tumour (11 points)
 
Last edited:
Top