- Awards
- 44
One of my all time favourite films. Yes it's a bit cheesy, yes it's overly sentimental, yes Mr Potter is more of a pantomime villain than a fully formed character and yes some of the characters are annoying (I want to slap Uncle Billy every time I watch it) but for me it's like having a long term partner, you love them not in spite of their flaws but because they make them more interesting and relatable.
That's a really nice way of looking at it.
I enjoyed reading your review Mel. I found it interesting as I haven’t seen this particular version since the 80s.
Oh great, and thanks.
The Alistair Sim and George C. Scott versions were always my favorites and for some reason this one never quite measured up for me. Maybe it’s the fact that I’m not exactly a big fan of musicals myself but I would like to go back and see this one now after about 35 years just to see if I would enjoy it more now at this age. I have a feeling I just might.
I did hesitate about watching when I saw it was a musical, but I'm really glad I did. As @Angela Christmas said many of the songs are forgettable, which is a shame, but I loved the performances, the atmosphere created in the film and the balance of darkness and humour. I think it works really well, especially in the non-musical moments.
The best is The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992) but this is joint second with the 1951 version with Alistair Sim.
The 1951 will be on my list to watch in future. Come to think of it, I'm not sure which versions of A Christmas Carol I've actually watched.
The Muppet Christmas Carol is great. My biggest bugbear with it (as with many Disney-related films) is the nannying aspect ("Gee. This moment's a bit frightening for younger children. Let's have two daft narrators to diffuse it by saying something lighthearted"). Apart from that it's brilliant.
In my opinon, what lets this film down is it's songs, other than Thank You Very Much and the brilliant ensemble cast scene that goes with it, and Father Christmas, every other song is instantly forgettable and for a musical that's a near disaster. If it only had a couple more really good songs I think this film would be a Christmas classic, annually screened on TV.
Agreed. Still, at least there was wisdom enough to reprise both the songs you mentioned later in the film.


