"Who Dunnit?" revealed 46 years ago today...

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
JR's gun-totin' assailant was revealed on 21 November 1980, receiving the largest American viewing audience for an entertainment program up until that time: 83 million viewers.

lead_large.jpg
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
I recently rewatched the entire arc, and so much of it is incredibly clever. I really like how, within the first two episodes, they ruled out all the suspects who might have wanted to kill J.R. for business reasons—making it clear that the motive was personal.

I also thought the handling of Kristin was very smart; for many viewers, she was surely the number-one suspect—not only because her character had effectively run its course, but also because, as both his sister-in-law and former mistress, she was a plausible culprit. When Kristin told Sue Ellen that Sue Ellen had shown up at her place, drunk and carrying a gun with the intent to kill J.R., one might have assumed Kristin took the gun and shot J.R. herself. However, when Kristin mentioned that Sue Ellen had spoken of someone named Dusty—a person Kristin didn’t know—it made the audience wonder if Kristin was actually telling the truth, effectively diverting suspicion away from her as the shooter.

I also find it interesting how the issue of Sue Ellen’s bail was handled. No one knew who had posted the bail, and even after Kristin had left, there was a brief moment where they wondered who might have put up the money—but then the subject was dropped, only to be revisited many episodes later. Of course, the viewers watching the original broadcast had no way of knowing that. I wonder if some fans at the time actually questioned who had paid the bail, or if most people simply forgot about it?

There are two things I find a bit disappointing about the plot: first, we didn’t get to see the other Ewings’ immediate reactions to the news that Kristin was the one who pulled the trigger; we only saw them when Kristin was speaking to the district attorney in front of the family at Southfork. And second, no one thanked Dr. Elby. If he hadn’t hypnotized Sue Ellen, we might never have found out who shot J.R. It would have been a nice touch if, before one of Sue Ellen’s subsequent appointments with Dr. Elby, J.R. had remarked that the doctor was truly worth his fee—or something to that effect.

Personally, I think the twist at the end of the episode regarding Kristin’s pregnancy is excellent; looking at the show’s trajectory, it paved the way for some compelling storylines. But I wonder—how did audiences back then react to the revelation that Kristin was pregnant? Were people rather disappointed—or even annoyed—by the fact that the final scene hinted that Kristin would not end up in prison? Or were they simply curious to see how J.R. would resolve the situation—or perhaps even glad that, due to her pregnancy, Kristin would likely remain in Dallas?
 
Last edited:

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
I recently rewatched the entire arc, and so much of it is incredibly clever. I really like how, within the first two episodes, they ruled out all the suspects who might have wanted to kill J.R. for business reasons—making it clear that the motive was personal.

I also thought the handling of Kristin was very smart; for many viewers, she was surely the number-one suspect—not only because her character had effectively run its course, but also because, as both his sister-in-law and former mistress, she was a plausible culprit. When Kristin told Sue Ellen that Sue Ellen had shown up at her place, drunk and carrying a gun with the intent to kill J.R., one might have assumed Kristin took the gun and shot J.R. herself. However, when Kristin mentioned that Sue Ellen had spoken of someone named Dusty—a person Kristin didn’t know—it made the audience wonder if Kristin was actually telling the truth, effectively diverting suspicion away from her as the shooter.

I also find it interesting how the issue of Sue Ellen’s bail was handled. No one knew who had posted the bail, and even after Kristin had left, there was a brief moment where they wondered who might have put up the money—but then the subject was dropped, only to be revisited many episodes later. Of course, the viewers watching the original broadcast had no way of knowing that. I wonder if some fans at the time actually questioned who had paid the bail, or if most people simply forgot about it?

There are two things I find a bit disappointing about the plot: first, we didn’t get to see the other Ewings’ immediate reactions to the news that Kristin was the one who pulled the trigger; we only saw them when Kristin was speaking to the district attorney in front of the family at Southfork. And second, no one thanked Dr. Elby. If he hadn’t hypnotized Sue Ellen, we might never have found out who shot J.R. It would have been a nice touch if, before one of Sue Ellen’s subsequent appointments with Dr. Elby, J.R. had remarked that the doctor was truly worth his fee—or something to that effect.

Personally, I think the twist at the end of the episode regarding Kristin’s pregnancy is excellent; looking at the show’s trajectory, it paved the way for some compelling storylines. But I wonder—how did audiences back then react to the revelation that Kristin was pregnant? Were people rather disappointed—or even annoyed—by the fact that the final scene hinted that Kristin would not end up in prison? Or were they simply curious to see how J.R. would resolve the situation—or perhaps even glad that, due to her pregnancy, Kristin would likely remain in Dallas?


I swear, I remember asking this question before, and I think it was answered, but we eventually find out it was Dusty, who put up the bail money, correct? I know you mentioned that the subject was revisited many episodes later, so that had to be Dusty, but for some reason, in my head, I never can recall that exact exchange where it's revealed.

You are right that you have to wonder if viewers were kinda still scratching their heads about who put up the money, but I'm guessing most people were too busy thinking about the resolution, etc, etc. so they probably mostly put how Sue Ellen's bail was posted out of their minds.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
I swear, I remember asking this question before, and I think it was answered, but we eventually find out it was Dusty, who put up the bail money, correct?
It wasn't until episode 16 of the fourth season that we learned Dusty had posted bail and was, therefore, still alive. As for Dusty, I’m actually quite surprised that he—who was thought to be dead at the time—was ranked first in the betting odds, with Kristin coming in only after him.


There is something regarding the ratings that I have noticed. The second episode of season four aired on Sunday, two days after the season premiere. This was clearly a deliberate move to ensure that Who Shot J.R.? aired on November 21st, rather than a week later, the Friday after Thanksgiving, which would have resulted in lower ratings. The fifth episode, which aired on November 28th, had the lowest rating of the first seven episodes of season four, at 34.0. So, the Thanksgiving weekend did indeed hurt Dallas. I still wonder how many viewers would have watched the fifth episode on a regular Friday, especially since the resolution was designed to sustain audience interest by leaving viewers eager to see how J.R. would deal with a pregnant Kristin. Looking at the ratings at the time, without considering the Thanksgiving context, one might think that many viewers had had enough of Dallas after the revelation.

I find it interesting that everyone except Lucy was affected by the shooting. She just carried on, met up with friends, and, most importantly, met Mitch in the very first episode of the fourth season. On the one hand, it was nice to have a storyline that didn't revolve around J.R., but on the other hand, it didn't really fit with the theme of the first few episodes. I was surprised that Donna returned in the "Who Shot J.R.?" episode and that a new storyline involving Cliff began. That was clever, but was it really a reason for viewers who tuned in specifically for that episode to come back next time?

Looking at episode 5 (and those that follow), I’m actually glad that the first four episodes included the introduction of Mitch and the return of Donna; given how quickly Sue Ellen reconciled with J.R. and joined him in opposing Bobby, the whole situation felt like a new story arc, and it was a good thing that other plot threads had already been set in motion.
 
Last edited:
Top